Skip to content

A time-domain adversarial example demonstrating the failure of H1 elements in a-ϕ electromagnetic simulation

Timothy Carlson, Sanjay Govindjee

math.NAarXiv:2611.26546

Abstract

Frequently, H1 continuous finite elements are used in computational electromagnetics despite it being widely known that such an interpolation is not guaranteed to furnish reliable approximations of solutions to general initial/boundary value problems. It is mathematically more natural to use H(Curl) elements (edge elements) than H1 elements, since the former form part of a discrete complex that respects the differential-geometric structure of Maxwell's equations while the latter do not. However, most work discussing the failure of H1 elements for electromagnetics is esoteric and concrete examples demonstrating the clear advantage of edge elements are generally restricted to quasi-static, frequency-domain, or eigenvalue problems. In this work, we summarize essential facts regarding H1 and H(Curl) elements and present a physically feasible yet intentionally adversarial time-domain eddy-current example demonstrating the failure of gauge-penalized H1 elements in an a-ϕ formulation compared to gauge-free mixed scalar/edge H1/H(Curl) elements. The results indicate that edge elements can be used to furnish reasonable results for general loading conditions, whereas penalized H1 elements fail (e.g., converge to an incorrect state) even with mesh refinement.

Create a lesson