Constraining non standard recombination: A worked example

Abstract

We fit the BOOMERANG, MAXIMA and COBE/DMR measurements of the cosmic microwave background anisotropy in spatially flat cosmological models where departures from standard recombination of the primeval plasma are parametrized through a change in the fine structure constant $\alpha$ compared to its present value. In addition to $\alpha$ we vary the baryon and dark matter densities, the spectral index of scalar fluctuations, and the Hubble constant. Within the class of models considered, the lack of a prominent second acoustic peak in the measured spectrum can be accomodated either by a relatively large baryon density, by a tilt towards the red in the spectrum of density fluctuations, or by a delay in the time at which neutral hydrogen formed. The ratio between the second and first peak decreases by around 25% either if the baryon density $\Omega_bh^2$ is increased or the spectral index $n$ decreased by a comparable amount, or if neutral hydrogen formed at a redshift $z_*$ about 15% smaller than its standard value. We find that the present data is best fitted by a delay in recombination, with a lower baryon density than the best fit if recombination is standard. Our best fit model has $z_*= 900$, $\Omega_bh^2=0.024$, $\Omega_mh^2=0.14$, $H_0=49$ and $n=1.02$. Compatible with present data at 95% confidence level $780< z_*<1150$, $0.018<\Omega_bh^2<0.036$, $0.07< \Omega_m h^2 < 0.3$ and $0.9<n<1.2$.