Mass Estimates of X-Ray Clusters

Abstract

We use cosmological gas dynamic simulations to investigate the accuracy of galaxy cluster mass estimates based on X-ray observations. The experiments follow the formation of clusters in different cosmological models and include the effects of gravity, pressure gradients, and hydrodynamical shocks. A subset of our ensemble also allows for feedback of mass and energy from galactic winds into the intracluster medium. We find that mass estimates based on the hydrostatic, isothermal beta-model are remarkably accurate when evaluated at radii where the cluster mean density is between 500-2500 times the critical density. Applied to 174 artificial ROSAT images constructed from the simulations, the distribution of the estimated-to-true mass ratio is nearly unbiased and has a standard deviation of 14-29%. The scatter can be considerably reduced (to 8-15%) by using an alternative mass estimator that exploits the tightness of the mass-temperature relation found in the simulations. The improvement over beta-model estimates is due to the elimination of the variance contributed by the gas outer slope parameter. We discuss these findings and their implications for recent measurements of cluster baryon fractions.