Chemical Abundance Constraints on White Dwarfs as Halo Dark Matter

Abstract

We examine the chemical abundance constraints on a population of white dwarfs in the Halo of our Galaxy. We are motivated by microlensing evidence for massive compact halo objects (Machos) in the Galactic Halo, but our work constrains white dwarfs in the Halo regardless of what the Machos are. We focus on the composition of the material that would be ejected as the white dwarfs are formed; abundance patterns in the ejecta strongly constrain white dwarf production scenarios. Using both analytical and numerical chemical evolution models, we confirm that very strong constraints come from Galactic Pop II and extragalactic carbon abundances. We also point out that depending on the stellar model, significant nitrogen is produced rather than carbon. The combined constraints from C and N give $\Omega_{WD} h < 2 \times 10^{-4}$ from comparison with the low C and N abundances in the Ly$\alpha$ forest. We note, however, that these results are subject to uncertainties regarding the nucleosynthesis of low-metallicity stars. We thus investigate additional constraints from D and $^4$He, finding that these light elements can be kept within observational limits only for $\Omega_{WD} \la 0.003$ and for a white dwarf progenitor initial mass function sharply peaked at low mass (2$M_\odot$). Finally, we consider a Galactic wind, which is required to remove the ejecta accompanying white dwarf production from the galaxy. We show that such a wind can be driven by Type Ia supernovae arising from the white dwarfs themselves, but these supernovae also lead to unacceptably large abundances of iron. We conclude that abundance constraints exclude white dwarfs as Machos. (abridged)