The Range of Validity for the Kelvin Force
Mario Liu
Abstract
In a recent Letter, Luo, Du and Huang reported a novel convective instability driven by a force rarely studied before -- that exerted by an external magnetic field on a strongly magnetizable liquid. The associated physics is surprisingly rich and promises many more interesting results for the future. Unfortunately, the analysis starts from a misconception and employs the Kelvin force outside its range of validity. Since few would recognize this as a mistake, and since its consequence in the given experiment is particularly direct and critical, this is a point well worth being clarified, and clearly understood.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Active Sculpting: morphodynamics of internally stirred active vesicles
Devadevan M M, Brato Chakrabarti
Emergent medium-range order in amorphous silicon
Zhen Zhang, Stephen R. Elliott, Yujie Wang et al.
Complex pattern in periodically driven binary Quincke colloids
Chuan Yu Zhang, Mu Yue Zhao, Xiao Yi Zhou et al.
Why shaking faster does not untangle: frequency-selective extraction of filaments from tangled matter
Ishant Tiwari, Sutikshan Bansal, Rosalind Huang et al.
Geometry-Encoded Hidden Orientational Memory
Vladimir A. Baulin
Curie-Weiss cell fluid model: Fitting to experimental critical-point data
I. V. Pylyuk, O. A. Dobush, M. P. Kozlovskii et al.