Comment on "Sound Modes broadening in Quasicrystals"
G. Coddens
Abstract
Recently de Boissieu et al. proposed an explanation for the broadening of acoustic modes observed in quasicrystals (QC). It is the transcription of a well-known model used for glasses. We raise two fundamental objections against applying it to QC. After the text of the Comment we report the methodology that has been used to thwart the publication of this Comment, which is perfectly valid.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Temperature dependence of the charge density from first principles: application to the (222) forbidden reflection in silicon
Jean Paul Nery, Raveena Gupta, Olle Hellman et al.
Coupled anisotropic weak topological states and Floquet mixed-parity altermagnetism in two-dimensional Su-Schrieffer-Heeger models
Kunyuan Feng, Xibin Liu, Chenchen Liu et al.
Grain Boundary Phase Transitions Enable Diffusionless Climb of Disconnections
Md Sharier Nazim, Giacomo Po, Nikhil Chandra Admal
3D Cloud Component Analysis of Atomic Structures
Pai Li
Benchmarking of Fast and Interpretable UF Machine Learning Potentials
Pawan Prakash, Sam Dong, Richard G. Hennig
Grain-Boundary Premelting in High-Entropy Transition Metal Carbides
Marium M. Mou, Caleb Schenck, Samuel E. Daigle et al.