Comment on "Spurious fixed points in frustrated magnets," cond-mat/0609285
Andrea Pelissetto, Ettore Vicari
Abstract
We critically discuss the arguments reported in cond-mat/0609285 by B. Delamotte, Yu. Holovatch, D. Ivaneyko, D. Mouhanna, and M. Tissier. We show that their conclusions are not theoretically founded. They are contradicted by theoretical arguments and numerical results. On the contrary, perturbative field theory provides a robust evidence for the existence of chiral fixed points in O(2) X O(N) systems with N>=2. The three-dimensional perturbative results are consistent with theory and with all available experimental and Monte Carlo results. They provide a consistent scenario for the critical behavior of chiral systems.
Create a lesson
Related papers
A Human-AI Theorem Connecting Spontaneous and Field-Induced Mechanisms of Collective Behavior in One Dimension
Weiguo Yin
Exact joint eigenvalue densities of non-Hermitian random matrices are Calogero scattering states
Zhenyu Xiao, Ze Chen, Yifei Liu et al.
Duality between the level statistics of Hermitian and non-Hermitian random matrices
Ze Chen, Zhenyu Xiao, Yifei Liu et al.
Nonlinear Fluctuating Hydrodynamics from Interacting Noisy Quantum Matter
Alexios Christopoulos, João Costa, Stefano Scopa et al.
Bayesian Tracking of a Diffusing Target in Two and Three Dimensions
Ewan McCulloch, Adam Nahum
Overcoming critical slowing down in frustrated spin systems by learned multiscale sampling
Gabriele Bandini, Giulio Biroli, Patrick Charbonneau et al.