Equivalence of two thermostatistical formalisms based on the Havrda&Charvat-Daroczy-Tsallis entropies

Abstract

We show that the latest thermostatistical formalism based on the Havrda & Charvat-Daróczy-Tsallis entropy $S_q [ ρ] = (q-1)^{-1}(1- tr (ρ^q))$ proposed by Tsallis, Mendes and Plastino is {\em equivalent} to the first one proposed by Tsallis in 1988. Here, equivalent means: {\em the ``equilibrium'' state predicted by either formalism using $q$ leads to the same expectation values for all observables as that predicted by the other formalism using $1/q$''}. We also point out once again that the basic property of {\em transitivity of equilibrium} (e.g., the $0^{th}$ Law of Thermodynamics) fails in these formalisms.