Answering Subcognitive Turing Test Questions: A Reply to French
Peter D. Turney
Abstract
Robert French has argued that a disembodied computer is incapable of passing a Turing Test that includes subcognitive questions. Subcognitive questions are designed to probe the network of cultural and perceptual associations that humans naturally develop as we live, embodied and embedded in the world. In this paper, I show how it is possible for a disembodied computer to answer subcognitive questions appropriately, contrary to French's claim. My approach to answering subcognitive questions is to use statistical information extracted from a very large collection of text. In particular, I show how it is possible to answer a sample of subcognitive questions taken from French, by issuing queries to a search engine that indexes about 350 million Web pages. This simple algorithm may shed light on the nature of human (sub-) cognition, but the scope of this paper is limited to demonstrating that French is mistaken: a disembodied computer can answer subcognitive questions.
Create a lesson
Related papers
RetireOPD: Self-Retiring On-Policy Distillation for Agentic Reinforcement Learning
Yan Yu, Zhengxi Lu, Yizhou Liu et al.
Harm Laundering in GPT Models: Evidence That Gender Discrimination Is Transformed Rather Than Reduced Across Safety-Trained Generations
Sarah Wyer, Sue Black, Noura Al Moubayed
dQwen3.5: Hybrid-Attention Diffusion Language Models
Anton Xue, Litu Rout, Aditya Akella et al.
On-Demand Attention: Language Models Know When to Recall
Haibo Feng, Ruiqi Liang, Hanyang Peng et al.
Summarization Bias: The Directional Collapse of Objective Projection into Told-Mode Labels in Large Language Models --- A Conceptual Framework and Registered Test Protocol
Levent Bulut
HerHealthEval: Evaluating Multilingual and Register-Sensitive Understanding of Women's Health Communication
Hassan Saeed Hassan Albattra, Mazen Mohammed Bahgat, Rahatara Ferdousi et al.