Critical points in an algebra of elementary embeddings, II

Abstract

In this paper, we continue the study of a left-distributive algebra of elementary embeddings from the collection of sets of rank less than lambda to itself, as well as related finite left-distributive algebras (which can be defined without reference to large cardinals). In particular, we look at the critical points (least ordinals moved) of the elementary embeddings; simple statements about these ordinals can be reformulated as purely algebraic statements concerning the left distributive law. Previously, lower bounds on the number of critical points have been used to show that certain such algebraic statements, known to follow from large cardinals, require more than Primitive Recursive Arithmetic to prove. Here we present the first few steps of a program that, if it can be carried to completion, should give exact computations of the number of critical points, thereby showing that hypotheses only slightly beyond Primitive Recursive Arithmetic would suffice to prove the aforementioned algebraic statements. Some of the main results here were discovered through examination of bit patterns from extensive calculations in the finite algebras; this may be the first serious example of computer-aided research in the theory of large cardinals. The results in this paper have a large overlap with results of A. Drapal, which were obtained independently at about the same time, but from a quite different point of view.