A remark on an ansatz by M.W. Evans and the so-called Einstein-Cartan-Evans unified field theory
Friedrich W. Hehl
Abstract
M.W.Evans tried to relate the electromagnetic field strength to the torsion of a Riemann-Cartan spacetime. We show that this ansatz is untenable for at least two reasons: (i) Geometry: Torsion is related to the (external) translation group and cannot be linked to an internal group, like the U(1) group of electrodynamics. (ii) Electrodynamics: The electromagnetic field strength as a 2-form carries 6 independent components, whereas Evans' electromagnetic construct F is a vector-valued 2-form with 24 independent components. This doesn't match. One of these reasons is already enough to disprove the ansatz of Evans.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Covariant Electrodynamics with a Scalar Degree of Freedom
Seil Sautbekov
Electromagnetic Radiation from a Neutralized Polarized Sphere with Two Conserved Currents for One Charge History
Natan Rentzber
The Photon Gas in Classical Mechanics: A Statistical-Mechanical Treatment of Classical Field Theory
Farhang Loran, Saman Moghimi-Araghi
Hydrogen Molecular Ion and Molecule in Classical Electrodynamics with Classical Zero-Point Radiation
Timothy H. Boyer
Spheroid rolling up on diverging inclines
Khanh P. M. Hoang, Duy V. Nguyen
Scalar-Longitudinal Radiation in Extended Electrodynamics with Multipole Theory and a Compensated Source Model
Natan Rentzber