Comment on "Comment on Galina Weinstein's article entitled 'Convergences and Divergences: Einstein Poincaré and Special Relativity' "This paper provides a systematic response to the criticisms raised by Jean-Marc Ginoux in response to my review of his book on the history of relativity. Whereas my review was written in a strictly…Galina Weinstein·Oct 4, 2025SaveLearn
A century of the Bose-Einstein condensation concept and half a century of the JINR experiments for observation of condensate in the superfluid 4He (He II)This short review is devoted to celebration of two major events in quantum physics. The first one is the birth of the concept of Bose-Einstein condensation (1925) and the second is the experimental…Valentin Zagrebnov·Oct 3, 2025SaveLearn
An account of the arrow of time when scale is surplusExisting accounts of the cosmological arrow of time face a dilemma: generalist approaches that posit time-asymmetric laws lack independent motivation, while particularist approaches that invoke a…Sean Gryb, Simon Friederich·Oct 3, 2025SaveLearn
Lorentz, Poincaré, and Einstein: Rethinking Doppler, Aberration, and the Fresnel DragThis paper examines Lorentz's 1895 derivations of the classical Doppler formula and Fresnel drag, Einstein's 1905 derivation of the relativistic Doppler effect and aberration, and…Galina Weinstein·Sep 30, 2025SaveLearn
Charge quantisation without compactness: the Higgs and Yukawa mechanisms from matter geometryIn the geometry-first formulation of gauge theory Gomesinternal, Hermitian vector bundles and their covariant derivatives are the primitive objects. Here gauge groups arise only as…Henrique Gomes·Sep 28, 2025SaveLearn
Naturalistic intuitionism for physicsRecently, a novel intuitionistic reconstruction of the foundations of physics has been primarily developed by Nicolas Gisin and Flavio Del Santo drawing on naturalism. Our goal in this paper is to…Bruno Bentzen, Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin·Sep 26, 2025SaveLearn
Is string field theory background independent?String field theory is supposed to stand to perturbative string theory as quantum field theory stands to single-particle quantum theory; as such, it purports to offer a substantially more general and…Bhanu Narra, James Read, Matěj Krátký·Sep 25, 2025SaveLearn
Comments on Weinstein's comments arXiv: 2509.09361 & 2510.03793In 2024, after thirty years of research on this subject, I published a book entitled: Poincaré, Einstein and the discovery of special relativity. An end to the controversy Ginoux2024.…Jean-Marc Ginoux·Sep 25, 2025SaveLearn
On functional freedom and Penrose's critiques of string theoryIn his The Road to Reality as well as in his Fashion, Faith and Fantasy, Roger Penrose criticises string theory and its practitioners from a variety of angles ranging from conceptual, technical, and…Matěj Krátký, James Read·Sep 25, 2025SaveLearn
The Aharonov-Bohm effect: reality and folkloreThe Aharonov-Bohm (A-B) effect has been a major focus of the foundations of physics. And yet, much confusion persists. In particular, the effect purportedly leads to a dilemma: on one horn, we have a…Henrique Gomes·Sep 23, 2025SaveLearn
Dualities in PhysicsFor more than half a century, dualities have been at the heart of modern physics. From quantum mechanics to statistical mechanics, condensed matter physics, quantum field theory and quantum gravity,…Sebastian De Haro, Enrico Cinti·Sep 19, 2025SaveLearn
Chaotic interaction between thermodynamic systemsIn previous study [1], we proposed a new physical law applicable to both particle and thermodynamical systems. Additionally, we introduced a physical definition of chaos and self-organization. In the…E. Aydiner·Sep 19, 2025SaveLearn
Der Stern von Bethlehem -- Einige Theorien und Hintergruende: Von der altorientalischen Astrologie ueber Kepler zu NewtonMany have have taken in hand to write a treatise on the Star of Bethlehem, particularly on Kepler's explanation as a stellar birth, triggered by Mars joining a great conjunction (a meeting of…Stephan F. Huckemann·Sep 18, 2025SaveLearn
Gauge symmetry and the arrow of time: How to count what countsThis thesis addresses two major problems in the philosophy of physics. The first is how to identify the minimal physical content of a theory; that is, what features of a theory are truly needed to…Sean Gryb·Sep 18, 2025SaveLearn
How are Scientific Concepts Birthed? Typing Rules of Concept Formation in Theoretical Physics ReasoningThis work aims to formalize some of the ways scientific concepts are formed in the process of theoretical physics discovery. Since this may at first seem like a task beyond the scope of the exact…Omar Aguilar, Anthony Aguirre·Sep 12, 2025SaveLearn
The Rapid Arrival of Josiah Willard Gibbs's Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics in European University LibrariesThis note offers an overview of how Josiah Willard Gibbs's Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, published simultaneously in London and New York in 1902, spread through European…Hector Giacomini·Sep 12, 2025SaveLearn
Convergences and Divergences: Einstein, Poincaré, and Special RelativityJean-Marc Ginoux's recent book, "Poincaré, Einstein and the Discovery of Special Relativity: An End to the Controversy" (2024), seeks to close the debate over the respective roles of…Galina Weinstein·Sep 11, 2025SaveLearn
A.P. Balachandran: Living in PhysicsA.P. Balachandran was a theoretical physicist of extraordinary versatility and originality. In a career spanning over six decades, he made many significant contributions to quantum field theory and…V. P. Nair·Sep 7, 2025SaveLearn
Holistic Versus Fragmented Multiverses: Empirical Access via Causal and Grounding SignaturesCan multiverse hypotheses ever receive empirical support? Critics argue that multiverse scenarios posit unobservable entities, face severe underdetermination, or fall outside the bounds of science.…Baptiste Le Bihan·Sep 5, 2025SaveLearn
Einstein's Hidden Scaffolding, with a Glance at PoincaréThis paper reconstructs the derivations underlying the kinematical part of Einstein's 1905 special relativity paper, emphasizing their operational clarity and minimalist use of mathematics.…Galina Weinstein·Sep 2, 2025SaveLearn
From Faraday and Maxwell to Quantum Physics. The later story of the Electromagnetic Vector PotentialWith the advent of quantum mechanics by Heisenberg in 1925 exactly a century ago, the quantization of the electromagnetic field became an important goal for our founding fathers, whom we are here to…Tuck Choy, Miguel Ortuno·Aug 31, 2025SaveLearn
Un avenir commun au sein de la société numériqueToday, data and information have become overabundant resources within a global network of machines that exchange signals at speeds approaching that of light. In this highly saturated environment,…Miguel Vanvlasselaer·Aug 31, 2025SaveLearn
Origins of the Ising modelIn 1925, Ernest Ising published a paper analyzing a model proposed in 1920 by Wilhelm Lenz for ferromagnetism. The model is composed of constituent units that take only two states and interact only…Mário J. de Oliveira·Aug 30, 2025SaveLearn
English translation of the paper "Electromagnetic field inside a plane-parallel layer in the resonant absorption regime" (1962) by A. P. Khapalyuk: Pioneering study on coherent perfect absorptionIn 1962, Belarusian physicist A. P. Khapalyuk has published the paper [Doklady Akademii nauk BSSR, volume 6, issue 5, pages 301-304] devoted to the effect of resonant absorption of light in a layer…Denis V. Novitsky·Aug 27, 2025SaveLearn
Reflections of Sadi CarnotThe Carnot theory is unique among the theories of heat developed before the emergence of thermodynamics because it considers the relationship between heat and work. The theory is contained in…Mário José de Oliveira·Aug 23, 2025SaveLearn