A Unified Symmetry Framework For In-plane Anomalous Hall effect

Abstract

The in-plane anomalous Hall effect (IPAHE), driven by an in-plane net magnetization or an applied magnetic field, challenges the conventional anomalous Hall paradigm. Despite growing interest, a unified symmetry principle governing these phenomena has remained elusive. Here, we establish a comprehensive symmetry framework that bridges the spin space group, which dictates the magnetic geometry, with the magnetic space group, which governs the anomalous Hall response. We show that spontaneous IPAHE can emerge in ferromagnets when spin-orbit-coupling-induced spin-group symmetry breaking permits additional net magnetization directions. For field-induced IPAHE, we analyze how an applied magnetic field reduces the symmetries of all 122 magnetic point groups and identify 54 groups that support IPAHE. Our framework naturally predicts IPAHE in a broad class of unconventional magnets, including altermagnets and odd-parity magnets. In particular, symmetry analysis reveals characteristic one-, two-, or three-fold angular harmonics of the Hall conductance under an in-plane rotating field, providing a symmetry-resolved fingerprint for unconventional magnetism. Using this framework, we screen the MAGNDATA database and identify candidate materials supporting spontaneous or field-induced IPAHE, encompassing ferromagnets, antiferromagnets, and unconventional magnets. Finally, we validate the symmetry predictions through first-principles calculations for two representative materials.