Beyond Problem Solving: Large Language Models for Emotional and Reflective Support in Mathematics Learning

Abstract

Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITSs) traditionally focus their adaptive support on cognitive aspects of learning. Although effective, little is known about how such systems can be enhanced by addressing students' emotional states. In particular, the role of mindful interventions for supporting student learning and experiences in adaptive math learning remains underexplored. We developed "Math with Matt", an ITS that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to provide both cognitive and emotional support in algebra learning. The system offers 1) an LLM-based mindful chat that delivers context-sensitive emotional support through a pedagogical agent Matt, and 2) mindful feedback and hint messages (not just evaluative) to enhance learning experiences and reduce math anxiety. We conducted a classroom study with 7th graders, comparing a Mindful version against a version with cognitive support only. Overall, the ITS reduced executive state-math anxiety and improved students' math learning, though no significant differences emerged between the conditions. However, students with the mindfulness interventions showed higher learning efficiency and well-balanced problem-solving behavior, since they achieve a similar level of math learning with less learning time and fewer requested hints compared to the Cognitive version. Additionally, they reported that the pedagogical agent felt more supportive and caring than students in the cognitive condition. Our study demonstrates the feasibility and scalability of integrating mindfulness into ITSs through LLM-based interactions and positions LLMs as an adaptive, socio-emotional layer within cognitive math tutoring.