Do links to retracted papers predict future retractions? An out-of-sample test on the open biomedical citation graph
Hossein Mohasel Arjomandi
Abstract
Tools that screen manuscripts for research-integrity problems flag papers that cite retracted work, and retrospective studies report that such papers are retracted more often. This study tests the signal prospectively on open data. Predictors were computed on the January 2024 OpenCitations graph using the retractions known at that date, frozen, and compared with retractions in the Retraction Watch database from February 2024 to October 2026. The design was pre-specified. Among 10.5 million biomedical papers published 2015-2023, 2.1% cited a paper already retracted, and 4,323 were retracted later (0.041%). Citing a retracted paper raised the later retraction rate from 0.035% to 0.27% with one such reference; excluding reviews (post hoc), it rose to 2.3% with five or more. Within journal and publication year the odds ratio was 2.99 (95% CI 2.73-3.27), and 3.03 when reference-list length was also held fixed (post hoc), so the signal is not explained by retraction waves in journals or by long reference lists. As a screen it is weak: 0.9% of the 1,000 highest-ranked papers were retracted later (2.2% with reviews set aside, post hoc), and 84% of later retractions cite no retracted paper. When the time point was moved into the late-2023 retraction wave, the journal's own retraction rate became the far better screen. NIH-funded papers cited already-retracted work as often as other papers in the same journal and year. Links to retracted papers are a useful flag but not a screen on their own.
Create a lesson
Related papers
"I Don't Think It's a Scam": A First Look at Family Intervention Barriers in Elder Abuse Discussions on Reddit and Baidu Tieba
Yipeng Wang, Huy Gia Han Vu, Jiaming Liu et al.
Dessins d'Enfants as a Topological Lens on Temporal Hypergraphs
Mehmet Emin Aktas, Esra Akbas
A comparative exploration of Steinerberger curvature and resistance curvature in model and real-world complex networks
Madhumita Mondal, Priyank Vasu, Areejit Samal et al.
Finding Patient Zero in Temporal Contact Networks: A Comparative Study
Nathan Cincera Brack, Martin Sterchi, Lorenz Hilfiker et al.
Inferring Locations and Correcting Bias in Infectious Disease Data Using Human Mobility
Owen Tucker, Lily Wang, Ruochen Kong et al.
Longitudinal Multi-Dimensional Analysis of India-Pakistan Conflict Discourse on Reddit (2019-2025)
Yash Khare, Hunjun Shin, Mohit Singhal