Host Dependence and Line-of-Sight Effects on Galaxy-Galaxy Strong Lensing in Clusters

Abstract

The cross section for galaxy-galaxy strong lensing (GGSL) events in galaxy clusters has repeatedly been found to be higher in observations than in cosmological simulations. We revisit this discrepancy using updated simulation methodology and investigate the dependence of the GGSL probability, $P_{\rm GGSL}$, on host-cluster lensing properties, baryonic physics, and correlated and uncorrelated line-of-sight structure. We find that correlated material within $\sim 35$ cMpc of the cluster along the line of sight enhances $P_{\rm GGSL}$ by a few percent for typical systems and by up to $\sim15\%$ for the most efficient lenses. At fixed cluster mass, dark-matter-only simulations yield GGSL probabilities up to an order of magnitude lower than hydrodynamical simulations. We also find a strong dependence on the host-cluster Einstein radius, with an approximate scaling $P_{\rm GGSL} \propto θ_{\rm E}^{2}$. Matching simulated and observed clusters in both mass and Einstein radius seems to reduce the discrepancy relative to previous comparisons. However, our analysis does not clearly resolve the GGSL discrepancy, as the inferred tension depends strongly on the field-of-view definition: square fields are approximately consistent with simulations, while cluster member-bounded fields yield observed probabilities a factor of $\sim 2-3$ higher. Until observations and simulations share a matched selection function and matched measurement methodology, the residual tension cannot be cleanly attributed to either astrophysics or cosmology.